RESEARCH — CASE STUDY

1 in 4 email businesses fail their own deliverability test

Our own research study

22 of 93companies selling email services were not fully cold email ready themselves
93businesses scanned on public DNS, Oct 16 to 17, 2026
22 of 93not fully ready, 23.7 percent, roughly 1 in 4
15with DMARC still at p=none, the biggest single gap
52already enforcing DMARC at reject
7with no DMARC record at all
2with no SPF record at all

How it worked

STEP 1

Public DNS scan of 93 email and outreach vendors

STEP 2

SPF presence and policy read per domain

STEP 3

DKIM checked at common selectors

STEP 4

DMARC presence and enforcement policy recorded

OUTCOME

22 of 93 companies selling email services were not fully cold email ready themselves

Meet the study

Ninety-three businesses that sell email and outreach services, audited on their public DNS records on October 16 and 17, 2026: the same SPF, DKIM and DMARC checks they sell to their customers. Aggregate results only. No company is named, because the point is the pattern, not the embarrassment.

The challenge

Buyers of outreach services have no easy way to tell good infrastructure from theatre. Every vendor's page says deliverability matters. Almost nobody checks whether the vendor's own domain would survive the audit they are selling. We decided to be the ones who check.

The solution

Public records only

Each company's sending setup was read from public DNS: does SPF exist and how does it end, is DKIM published at the common selectors, and above all, what does the DMARC policy actually enforce. No emails were sent, no systems touched, nothing used that is not published for anyone to read.

A plain definition of ready

Fully ready meant the basics in place and enforcing: valid SPF, DKIM published, and DMARC at quarantine or reject. Anything less, including the very common p=none, counted as not fully ready.

The results

The 22 failures overlap, and they were not obscure settings: DMARC at p=none on 15, no DMARC record on 7, no DKIM found on 6, no SPF on 2. They were the first three checks on any deliverability audit.

If the sellers cannot pass, buyers have to check for themselves. That is why the checkers on this site are free: run your own domain through the Domain Health Checker and read what it actually says.

The return for buyers is the cheapest diligence there is. The scan costs nothing but public DNS lookups, and it found that roughly 1 in 4 vendors selling deliverability could not pass their own first three checks. Run the free check before paying anyone, including us.

FAQ

How was the scan done?

By reading public DNS records for each company's domain on October 16 and 17, 2026: SPF, DKIM and DMARC presence and policy. Everything used is published by the companies themselves for the whole internet to read.

What does fully ready mean?

Valid SPF, DKIM published and signing, and DMARC enforcing at quarantine or reject. p=none counts as not ready because it monitors spoofing without stopping any of it.

How do I check my own domain?

Run it through the free Domain Health Checker on this site. It reads the same public records this study used and tells you, in plain words, what is missing.

By the numbers

businesses scanned on public DNS, Oct 16 to 17, 202693
not fully ready, 23.7 percent, roughly 1 in 422 of 93
with DMARC still at p=none, the biggest single gap15
already enforcing DMARC at reject52
with no DMARC record at all7
with no SPF record at all2

Bars are scaled so very small and very large numbers fit on one chart. The values printed are exact.

THE ROI
22 of 93

vendors selling email services who could not pass the first checks themselves when scanned

Checking first costs nothing: 22 of 93 vendors selling these services failed their own first checks.

What was built

The concrete pieces this engagement shipped, in one list.

Your mail is being sent unauthenticated. Here is the full fix.

Lower stack cost. Back in the inbox. Built to send at any scale.

We rebuild it properly: secondary domains, inboxes, SPF, DKIM and DMARC set to enforcement, warmup and safe sending limits, blacklist monitoring on top. Send-ready in about 17 days. No campaigns, no copy, no lead lists. Infrastructure only.

Almost a decade building cold outreach infrastructure, including his own sending and verification stack built from scratch. 20+ B2B clients at companies worth $10M and above, all in tier one countries.

Free · Written plan + fixed price · No sales call required

More case studies

Lead dataA US M&A advisory firm (name withheld)
46,000

prospects matched on LinkedIn, 93% of the final list

151,218 rows in. 49,373 decision-makers out.

READ CASE STUDY →

ROIValid decision-maker leads at $0.067 each in the pilot, then all 49,373 scored for $1.54 total.

InfrastructureA US advisory firm's cold email program (name withheld)
100%

sender health at the end of the wave, with 1 hard bounce in the final campaign

30 inboxes. 1,596 sends. Zero burned.

READ CASE STUDY →

ROIZero inboxes burned: 1,596 sends delivered and the pool ended at 100% health, ready for the next wave.

OutreachPartner outreach for a US advisory firm (name withheld)
Step 2

the follow-up, not the first touch, produced the first interested partner reply

The first yes did not come from the first email

READ CASE STUDY →

ROI958 sends across the wave produced an interested partner and a $1,000 logged opportunity.

Copied
Free tools Get an inbox plan