Meet the firm
A US advisory firm that works with business owners on acquisitions and exits. Like most firms sitting on years of accumulated data, it had one giant workbook: 151,218 rows collected over time, in every shape, from every source.
The challenge
A raw workbook is not a lead list. It held staff, gatekeepers, duplicates and whole industries the firm never sells to. Emailing it as-is would have burned sending domains, wasted the sending budget on people who cannot say yes, and produced the usual result: bounces, spam complaints and silence.
The firm needed the opposite of more data. It needed fewer, better rows: only people who can actually sign.
The solution
Cut to decision-makers only
Every row was filtered to people who hold the pen: CEO, founder, owner or partner. The strict title cleanup of the manufacturing segment shows how hard the cut was. Of 18,257 rows, 12,084 survived: 5,408 CEOs, 4,449 owners, 1,200 founders and 1,027 partners. The 6,173 removed rows included 2,826 CFOs, 1,578 president-only titles, 1,086 COOs, 423 other chief officers and 242 principals. Vice presidents and department heads went too, unless the same person also held an ownership-level role.
Move, never copy
Kept leads were moved out of the source workbook, not copied. The main consolidation moved 33,198 rows into the manufacturing sheet, and a wider sweep then found 311 more decision-makers hiding under missed industry labels and company-name signals, taking the final count to 49,373. Every lead now lives in exactly one place, so no prospect can be emailed twice from two tabs, and the counts always reconcile.
The cut was deliberate in both directions: 27,482 non-decision-maker manufacturing rows (7,412 vice presidents, 6,636 presidents, 6,455 CFOs among them) were left in the workbook on purpose, not lost.
Score every single lead
All 49,373 surviving leads were scored on three sub-scores, decision power, business need and business substance, combined into one composite weighted 0.45 to need, 0.30 to substance and 0.25 to decision power. The tiers came out at 80 leads at 0.75 or higher, 27,425 in the middle band, and 21,868 below 0.55. The top composite was 0.7865. The whole scoring run cost $1.54 in total, with zero failed calls.
Pull the best buyers to the top
The 755 leads at a composite of 0.70 or higher were pulled into a Best Buyers tab, sorted best first, so outreach starts where the probability is highest.
Upload as a matched audience
The full list was uploaded to LinkedIn as a matched audience for the firm's advertising. Twenty-one stray email cells hiding in name and company fields were scrubbed first, the exact defect that gets audience files rejected, and zero rows were skipped. LinkedIn matched 46,000 of the 49,373, about 93%, and the audience sits at Ready.
The results
- 151,218 raw rows in the source workbook
- 49,373 decision-maker leads in the final list
- 755 best buyers ranked at the top, composite 0.70 or higher
- 46,000 matched on LinkedIn, about 93% of the upload
- $1.54 total cost to score the entire list
A second sprint for the same firm built a separate 33,049 lead workbook from Sales Navigator: 18,191 bulk leads, 3,665 valid and 11,193 risky or unknown. Of those, 14,861 emails were uploaded as another matched audience and 14,268 people were mapped by LinkedIn, about 96%, with the 18,191 bulk emails following as a second audience on November 1.
The economics are the story. In the strict pilot for this firm, 100 BounceVerify-valid decision-maker leads cost $6.69 in total, $0.067 per valid lead. The full 49,373 lead list was then scored for $1.54 all in. And the 27,482 rows a volume-first team would have emailed anyway were never sent to at all, which is bounce cost and reputation cost that simply never happened.
FAQ
What counts as a decision-maker?
CEO, founder, owner or partner. Titles below that level were removed unless the same person also held an ownership role, because outreach to people who cannot sign produces polite replies and no business.
What exactly did the cleanup remove?
In the strict pass, 6,173 rows: 2,826 CFOs, 1,578 president-only titles, 1,086 COOs, 423 other chief officers, 242 principals and the rest directors and blanks. A further 27,482 non-decision-maker rows were left in the source workbook deliberately, so the final sheet holds decision-makers only.
Why move leads instead of copying them?
Copying creates duplicates across tabs, and duplicates get emailed twice. Moving means each lead exists in exactly one place, the counts always add up, and nothing is contacted twice by accident.
How was the list scored?
Each lead was scored on decision power, business need and business substance, combined with need weighted highest at 0.45, then substance at 0.30, then decision power at 0.25. The ranking is relative: best first, not a promise about any single lead.
Can this be done with my list?
Yes. This is the same process we run before any campaign build: cut to decision-makers, remove what cannot buy, score what is left, and only then talk about sending.
